Whether you think Chen is a traitor, an alarmist, an opportunitst or a hero, one thing is certain: his defection has catapulted the topic of Chinese espionage into the global spotlight and is fast creating a public relations nightmare for China at a time when it would rather the world focus on the upcoming Beijing Olympics and all the great things China is doing to prepare for them. No such luck.
A week later, the Chinese spy affair is no joke. The incredulity has been tempered by news of two other Chinese security officials backing Chen and promising supporting documents. Now the Australian and Chinese governments are facing questions.
Potentially, it could be China’s worst nightmare, the beginning of new global scrutiny of its human rights abuses before the crowning ceremony of the nation’s economic and political emergence, the 2008 Beijing Olympics.
For the Howard Government, there is concern about why – at a time of close relations between Australia and China – it rebuffed Chen, and shunned a rich seam of information about China’s spy network in Australia, China and other countries.
From the mundane to the dramatic, from petty vandalism to high-tech eavesdropping and abductions, Chinese dissidents have a wealth of tales of Chinese harassment and surveillance.
It has always been assumed that China had an active spy network in Australia; every nation uses espionage and some intelligence officials are even formally revealed to foreign governments. But intelligence experts say the Chinese spy differently, relying heavily on informants in the Chinese diaspora. And what is emerging is a spy network far more extensive and more active than many thought. Just as damaging for China is new evidence of horrific and systematic abuses against dissidents back in their homeland.
Chen made the initial claims but, as he has gone back into hiding, Hao Fengjun, a member of China’s state security bureau who sought asylum in February, has filled out the picture of a sophisticated and widespread network of intelligence gathering.
A member of the notorious “610” unit that prosecuted Falun Gong in the northern Chinese city of Tianjin, he came to Australia with a file of highly sensitive information downloaded from his work computer. “It is not a question of 1000 spies in Australia, it is a network of informants, recruited and directed from outside the Chinese diplomatic missions in Australia. These persons report directly to the state security bureau in China,” he says.
A search of news headlines will show you that this is now a major international incident, and Australia comes across nearly as bad as China. (Well, not quite.) Reading the article cited above (especially the begining), I couldn’t help think this was movie material — the dashing young diplomat with wife and kids fleeing the torturing, blood-stained Chinese Gestapo only to find he was delivering himself to the enemy….
Pity, that Australia decided to cast itself as a villain when it could have been the knight in shining armor. The Australian media are having a field day savaging Howard for the way he botched this up.
The defection – or rather the attempted defection – of Chinese consular official Chen Yonglin is proving to be most revealing of the thinking in the Australian foreign policy establishment, and of our government’s singular lack of courage…
Make no mistake: in Beijing they are horrified by this defection. They know that if western intelligence gets the opportunity to thoroughly debrief Chen it will be a serious blow.
All this being so, Australia’s astonishing refusal to grant immediate asylum, forcing Chen to go underground rather than receiving immediate sanctuary (with the concomitant debriefing), requires some consideration.
“Some consideration” — how’s that for Australian understatedness? What he means is the government should be drawn and quartered. And it will be, at least in the eyes of the world.
Comments