Too much is already out there on this topic so I’ll try to be be brief.
Nothing is more depressing than seeing those on the right jump for joy over the Muslim youths rioting in Paris. They’re thrilled because it confirms how dysfunctional and bad France is, and confirms that Muslims are animals. (For a fine example, head over to this monstrous site — a real “hate site,” and one linked to enthusiastically by InstaPuppy and Michelle Malkin.) It’s depressing because their joy is ill-founded and based on two lies: 1.) that this is part of a worldwide Islamofascist “intifada,” and 2.) that the rioting is due to France’s liberal, multicultural, Muslim-loving tendencies.
Actually, France takes a rather right-wing, Charles Johnsonesque approach to Muslims, isolating them from mainstream society, ghettoizing them and enforcing a unicultural policy.
The government has been embarrassed by its inability to quell the disturbances, which have called into question its unique integration model, which discourages recognizing ethnic, religious or cultural differences in favor of French unity. There is no affirmative action, for example, and religious symbols, like the Muslim veil, are banned in schools.
And returing to No. 1, this isn’t about Muslim terrorism. It’s about poor disaffected youth on the fringes of society, warehoused in project housing with no hope and no future. The rioting may be totally wrong and inexcusable, but at least see it for what it is. It is not a 911-like attack, but the result of many years of stigmatization and poverty. First try to understand it, then criticize it. Is that too much to ask?
LGF Watch offers an eloquent and cogent reminder of how stupid Charles and Michelle and their lemming followers are being as they decry Muslims and the French and declare it proof of the failings of liberalism.
Senior European affairs analyst Charles Johnson seems to believe that Islam, and nothing else, is the “root cause” of the gang violence that has been plaguing France for the past ten days. Does the worldwide Pajamas Media empire now include on-the-ground news gatherers in Aulnay-sois-Bois? That would account for his unflinching certainty that the car-burnings are an “intifada” whose ultimate aim is to force Brigitte Bardot into a burqa. Or something.
But as Oscar Wilde once remarked, the truth is rarely pure and never simple. Unlike Charles, I don’t claim to know why the rioters are rioting, or how to make them stop. But it’s clear that Islam is just one of several possible contributing factors, which include chronic unemployment (would Charles hire a well-qualified Muslim?); racism (the French loathe Muslim Arabs almost as much as the lizards do); inept policy decisions, such as the suspension of community policing last year; political wrangling between two monumental egos at the head of the French government (Messieurs de Villepin and Sarkozy); and the failure of the French model of “uniculturalism.”
Yes, “uniculturalism.” Contrary to the conventional wisdom among the so-called “politically incorrect” right-wing élite, France and other European countries do not practice “multiculturalism.” For decades, France’s official policy has been to deny the existence of racial and ethnic differences among its citizens. There are no hyphenated Frenchmen — at least not officially, but as we all know, Frenchmen whose skin is the wrong color, or whose parents were born in the wrong country, are likely to find themselves warehoused in high-rise ghettoes. Out of sight, out of mind, and out of work — because as there are officially no ethnic groups in France, there’s no such thing as affirmative action either.
And this is the model to which the enemies of “multiculturalism” aspire….
So the next time you see a headline that reads “Muslim Rioting,” keep in mind that “Unemployed Rioting” or “Youth Rioting” or even “Male Rioting” would all be equally accurate.
Oddly enough, Michelle Malkin — perhaps inadvertently — touched on this when she headlined the troubles as “Muslim Immigrant Gang Violence.” Gang violence is exactly what it is. And gang violence can be found pretty much everywhere. It’s not a uniquely French problem, or a uniquely European problem, and certainly not a uniquely Muslim problem (Belfast, anyone?).
As we wait to see what happens, all we can do is hope that the rioting will subside, that the epidemic of car-burnings will recede to its usual background level, and that the French government can find the political will to solve the problem of the banlieues once and for all. And not just because this would annoy the right-wing élite, which is already breathlessly anticipating the spread of the violence to other countries in Europe.
Just two words, LGF Watch: Thank you. It’s so heartbreaking to see Michelle and Mark Steyn and InstaPundit and others, who really should know better, exploit this and use it to encourage yet more racism and hatred, without ever asking for perspective, without ever wondering why it happened, without ever looking beyond what they want to believe, i.e., that the Muslims and the French are each monolithic groups of very bad people who deserve the very worst.
Comments